NT Youth Detention: The Don Dale Scandal and What Changed (and Didn't)

The Night That Shocked Australia

On 25 July 2016, the ABC's Four Corners program broadcast footage that most Australians could barely believe was real. Inside the Don Dale Youth Detention Centre in Darwin, guards were shown tear-gassing children in their cells, strapping a teenager to a restraint chair with a spit hood over his head, and dragging young people across floors. The children were overwhelmingly Aboriginal.

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull announced a Royal Commission within 48 hours. It felt like a turning point.

It wasn't.

What the Royal Commission Found

The Royal Commission into the Protection and Detention of Children in the Northern Territory, led by Mick Gooda and Brian Martin, delivered its final report in November 2017. It was damning. Key findings included:

• The NT's youth justice system was chronically underfunded and poorly managed
• Children as young as 10 were being detained, often for minor offences
• Aboriginal children made up around 95% of the youth detention population despite being roughly 30% of the NT's youth population
• Solitary confinement, mechanical restraints, and chemical agents had been used routinely and unlawfully
• The child protection system was failing to intervene early, funnelling vulnerable kids into detention instead

The Commission made 227 recommendations covering everything from raising the age of criminal responsibility to investing in community-based diversion programs.

What Actually Changed

The NT Government accepted the recommendations in principle. Then, largely, got on with business as usual.

By 2023, the NT still had the highest youth incarceration rate in Australia - and one of the highest in the developed world. Aboriginal young people continue to represent over 90% of those in detention. The age of criminal responsibility in the NT remained at 10 years old until the federal government pushed through a national increase to 12 in 2023 - itself a compromise, with advocates calling for 14 as the internationally recommended standard.

In 2021, the NT Government spent approximately $1,100 per day per child in detention - compared to a fraction of that on the community programs proven to prevent offending in the first place. A 2022 report by NAAJA (North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency) found that many children in detention had never been convicted of any offence and were being held on remand, sometimes for months.

The much-discussed replacement for Don Dale - a new facility at Holtze - has faced repeated delays and cost blowouts, with the budget ballooning past $180 million. Meanwhile, the original Don Dale site continued operating long past when it was supposed to close.

Why Does This Keep Happening?

This is the uncomfortable question. The evidence on what works is not actually disputed:

So why does incarceration persist as the default?

Partly it's political optics. Being seen as "tough on crime" still wins votes in certain electorates, and the NT has a particular history of law-and-order politics that both Labor and the CLP (Country Liberal Party) have cynically exploited. The NT Labor government, which was in power during Don Dale and returned to government after it, has repeatedly promised reform while maintaining detention as the centrepiece of youth justice.

Partly it's structural inertia. Detention facilities employ people. Bureaucracies built around incarceration resist being wound down. Community organisations that could run diversion programs are chronically underfunded and lack the political connections of government agencies.

And partly - let's be honest - it's because the children affected are Aboriginal, poor, and from remote communities. They don't have lobbyists. They don't make donations to political parties. Their families have been systematically disempowered for generations.

The Federal Government's Role

This isn't just an NT problem to be fixed by Darwin politicians. The Commonwealth funds a significant portion of NT services and has constitutional levers it rarely uses. The Albanese Government committed to Closing the Gap targets that explicitly include reducing youth incarceration - yet federal investment in the community programs that would achieve this remains inadequate.

Both major parties have had opportunities to act decisively. Both have offered reports, reviews, and rhetoric. The gap between what the evidence recommends and what governments actually fund has not meaningfully closed.

Why Direct Democracy Matters Here

Here's what's striking: when Australians are actually asked whether they support locking up children - particularly for non-violent offences, particularly children who are themselves victims of neglect and abuse - the answer is overwhelmingly no. Public polling consistently shows support for rehabilitation, early intervention, and keeping kids out of the justice system altogether.

So why does policy look nothing like public values?

Because the people making decisions are insulated from accountability. They respond to party donors, to media cycles, to internal factional pressures. The Aboriginal families in Katherine or Tennant Creek who are watching their kids cycle through Don Dale have essentially no mechanism to change policy - except waiting for an election where youth justice will rank below the cost of living and interest rates.

Direct democracy changes that equation. When members vote directly on policy - and elected representatives are bound to follow those instructions - the interests of powerful institutions stop automatically outweighing the interests of vulnerable communities. Evidence-based policy stops being aspirational and starts being mandatory.

The Don Dale scandal told us exactly what was wrong and exactly how to fix it. What we've lacked is a political system willing to act on what it knows.

---

Want a say in policies like this one? Join Direct Democracy and vote directly on the issues that matter. Take our [policy quiz](https://directdemocracy.com.au/quiz) to see where you stand, or [become a member](https://directdemocracy.com.au/join) and help build a political system that actually listens.